Oysters are one of those rare ingredients that are just as magnificent cooked as they are raw. While there’s nothing quite like a fresh oyster—cold, briny, and tasting purely of the sea—a little heat can open up an entirely different set of possibilities. Whether broiled, grilled, fried, or tucked into a gumbo, they take on new dimensions of flavor without losing what makes them special in the first place. Before you dive in, brush up on your shucking technique, then work your way through some of our favorite ways to eat these bivalves, both on and off the shell.
Ginger and Turmeric Mignonette
A classic mignonette gets a golden, umami-forward makeover with the addition of soy sauce in this bright number from Charleston chef Derick Wade. Fresh ginger, lime juice, and rice vinegar provide a punchy acidity that pairs perfectly with the briny flavor of freshly shucked oysters and the earthiness of turmeric powder. Get the recipe >
Strawberry and Watermelon Mignonette
Also from chef Derick Wade, this red-hued version gets a boost of acidity from two kinds of vinegar while leaning into sweetness from the fruit that naturally complements the saltiness of oysters. Fresh jalapeño brings a bit of heat, rounding out the flavor profile. Get the recipe >
Chicken and Oyster Gumbo
Gumbo is one of New Orleans’ most famous dishes, and this version by local chef Dominick Lee hits all the notes. Chicken thighs and a full container of shucked oysters go into a cayenne-laced base built on the Louisiana holy trinity of onion, celery, and bell pepper. Take your time and make sure you don’t rush the roux or overcook the oysters. Serve atop steamed rice with a dollop of potato salad, as Lee does. Get the recipe >
Oyster Shooter
Eating oysters is for the bold, but drinking them shucked and submerged in a shot of chilled vodka is for the boldest. This savory shooter combines the classic companions lemon, cocktail sauce, and Worcestershire for a punchy way to get the party started. Only use the freshest oysters as the quality of ingredients makes or breaks this simple dish. Get the recipe >
Oyster Chowder With Bacon, Corn, and Fennel
If you’re not a fan of raw oysters, this dish makes one of the best arguments for eating them cooked. Fresh summer corn and crisp fennel lend sweet and crunchy vegetal notes, while smoky bacon, heavy cream, and juices from the oysters add body. Get the recipe >
Casamento’s Fried Oyster Loaf Sandwich
Plump Louisiana oysters are dredged in corn flour and fried in lard, then piled high on thick buttered and broiled white bread with cocktail sauce, hot sauce, and a squeeze of lemon. Purists add nothing else, but you’re welcome to dress it up with lettuce, tomato, and mayo. The main thing to remember is that simplicity is key. Get the recipe >
Broiled Oysters With Parmigiano and ’Nduja
Whoever said fish and cheese don’t belong together never tried this: oysters topped with melted Parmigiano-Reggiano and a spoonful of ’nduja, the spicy, spreadable sausage. The embellished half shells are then broiled until blistered. Get the recipe >
Lowcountry Brown Oyster Stew
This rich stew from Charleston chef Amethyst Ganaway is a tribute to the region’s matriarchs of Gullah Geechee cuisine. Instead of using traditional smoked pork, Ganaway layers in flavor with dawadawa, a fermented locust bean powder that adds umami to many Nigerian-style stews and soups. She also mixes in crawfish powder and a spiced roux that’s cooked until it turns a deep, chocolatey brown. Get the recipe >
Oysters With Griddled Lemon “Curd”
Lemon gets a less traditional preparation in this recipe: Slices are charred with basil until sweet and deeply golden, then blended into a bittersweet, lightly smoky paste. It’s pithy and complex, and it turns to something truly unique when combined with the brine of freshly shucked oysters. Get the recipe >
Ember-Roasted Oysters With Love Butter
Shucked oysters go straight onto a bed of hot embers, then they get topped with a vivid green compound butter packed with lovage—an herb with a bright, celery-like flavor—that melts into the briny liquor. It comes together in minutes and delivers a wonderfully complex finish. Get the recipe >
Fried Oyster Po’Boys With Kale and Tartar Sauce
Kale on a po’boy may raise eyebrows among traditionalists, but the bitter green turns out to be a wonderful foil for the richness of a deep-fried oyster. Crispy, cornmeal-coated bivalves, homemade tartar sauce, and crusty French bread do the rest of the work. Get the recipe >
Jalapeño Mignonette
Charleston chef Alex Lira starts this bright, spicy condiment with a cold pickle brine of champagne vinegar, white wine, coriander, fennel, and thyme, which gets poured over jalapeño rings and left to mellow overnight. The strained liquid is then blended with yuzu juice and shallots for something clean and gently spicy. Get the recipe >
Grilled Oysters With Pecorino and Shaved Bottarga
New Orleans chef Justin Devillier grills large Gulf oysters just until their juices bubble and the meat begins to curl, then he finishes them with a dusting of aged Pecorino Romano and a shaving of bottarga (sun-cured fish roe) for a salty finish. Large oysters work better in this recipe as their bigger shells can hold more toppings. Get the recipe >
Pork Rind Oyster Snacks
Consider this riff on the “roosters” bar snack—popular in the South and traditionally served with a saltine and chased with a cold beer—to be a playful version of surf and turf. Here, the bivalves sit atop a crunchy pork rind, finished with pickled jalapeño for a briny, savory, and spicy bite. Get the recipe >
José Andrés’ Grilled Oysters
In this simple recipe, chef José Andrés imparts a smoky flavor by splashing the oyster shells with butter as they grill. The molten fat burns up in the heat, allowing the oysters to soak in the flavor while they finish cooking. Get the recipe >
Veal Chops With Morels, Wilted Lettuce, Oysters, and Garlic-Parmesan Sauce
Seared veal chops are surrounded by briefly charred oysters, wilted butter lettuce, a silky morel ragù made with vin jaune, and a garlic-parmesan sauce. It’s classic French luxury. Get the recipe >
Grilled Oysters on a Bed of Salt
Rather than setting oysters directly onto the grates of a grill, Gramercy Tavern chef Michael Anthony nestles them into a salt-lined baking dish set over a fire. The salt evenly distributes heat, making it nearly impossible to overcook the meat or lose any precious liquor. Get the recipe >
Oysters With Grilled Pineapple and Thai Basil
A departure from the usual lemon, mignonette, and cocktail sauce toppings, this preparation chars fish sauce-glazed pineapple until sweet and lightly blackened, then dices it fine and spoons it over freshly shucked oysters with Thai basil, shallot, and a slices of fresh chile. A squeeze of lime adds tartness to round out the combination. Get the recipe >
Raw Oysters With Lemon Oil and Urfa Biber
A hit of lemon zest-infused oil and a squeeze of fresh lemon provide all the acidity needed here. The real intrigue comes from urfa biber—a smoky Turkish chile that adds warmth without overpowering the delicate shellfish. Get the recipe >
Broiled Oysters With Spinach and Brown Butter Hollandaise
We can think of lots of dishes that play well with hollandaise, and this one is no exception: Briny oysters are topped with wilted spinach and chorizo, then doused in the nutty brown butter sauce and broiled until just bronzed and bubbling. Serve with a splash of mignonette to cut through the richness. Get the recipe >
Oyster Pie With Buttermilk Biscuits
A creamy filling of oysters, Swiss chard, ham, and a touch of absinthe gets topped with from-scratch buttermilk biscuits and is baked until golden and bubbling. Part pot pie, part oyster stew, what’s not to love? Get the recipe >
Oyster Stuffing
If you’re like us, stuffing is toward the top of the Thanksgiving food pyramid. This version of our favorite carby side dish makes use of bacon, lots of herbs, and plenty of shucked oysters. It’s a distinctively New England, almost chowder-esque rendition that’s perfect for any feasting table. Get the recipe >
Oysters DuPont
From Florida chef Jodi Perez, these broiled oysters feature a Mediterranean twist. They’re topped with a garlic-herb oil, sweet crabmeat, feta, and capers, and are broiled until golden and bubbly. Take a cue from Perez and serve them with hot sauce and toasted ciabatta for mopping up the juices. Get the recipe >
The post Our 23 Favorite Ways to Eat Oysters appeared first on Saveur.
