In Manhattan‘s eclectic West Village neighborhood, notable property listings are a regular occurrence—but few dwellings sport such a rare blend of architectural acclaim and celebrity heritage as the city’s most narrow townhouse, which has just returned to the market for $4.19 million.
Cemented in the history books for its skinny stature, it is the narrowest townhouse in the Big Apple, according to the New York City Landmarks Preservation Committee. The property measures just 9.5 feet across.
But the home’s legacy dates back much further than its addition to the city record. The property was originally built in 1873 on top of a former carriage entrance, and it features the Dutch-inspired brick façade that was popular during that era.
A half-century after the townhouse at 75 1/2 Bedford St. was completed, poet and playwright Edna St. Vincent Millay and her husband, Eugen Jan Boissevain, took up residence. The same year they moved in, St. Vincent Millay won the Pulitzer Prize for her poem “Ballad of the Harpweaver.”
The building’s other notable residents include anthropologist Margaret Mead and cartoonist William Steig. Actors Cary Grant and John Barrymore, who, like St. Vincent Millay, were involved with the local Cherry Lane Theater, also stayed in the home.
That impressive legacy is just one of the many alluring aspects of the home, according to listing agent Cortnee Glasser, of Sotheby’s International Realty – East Side Manhattan Brokerage.
“The potential buyer would be drawn to the home’s cultural legacy and coveted West Village address,” says Glasser of the three-bedroom, two-bath property. “It’s perfect for those seeking a one-of-a-kind residence that captures the spirit of old New York with modern comforts.”
While the 152-year-old home boasts plenty of historical charm, it has undergone several rounds of renovations and restorations as it has changed hands. Among the upgrades are a finished lower level and a newly added skylight on an upper floor.
Original details that remain include four wood-burning fireplaces framed in travertine. Three of those fireplaces are in the bedrooms, and one is in a bath.
“This unique, legendary home, famously known as The Millay House, was meticulously renovated with modern finishes, while retaining its original character and pedigree,” the listing states.
Natural light is in abundance throughout, thanks to not only the aforementioned skylight but also floor-to-ceiling French doors on the first two levels.
In total, the dwelling offers just over 1,100 square feet of living space, but the listing makes clear that every inch of that space has been artfully designed to make it feel light, airy, and open.
“There is wonderful light throughout the house from the large skylight on the upper level, oversized windows in the front, and floor-to-ceiling French doors on the first two levels,” the listing notes.
Similarly, every finish and decor decision has been made with lasting luxury in mind.
“Leave the Dutch door on the ground floor garden level open, enjoy a fresh breeze, and cook in your well-appointed kitchen with custom millwork, Italian marble countertops and backsplash, built-in Miele coffee maker and vented oven,” the description states.
A 150-square-foot private, landscaped garden that’s accessible from the kitchen may entice a seasoned entertainer to put in an offer.
“It’s ideal for dinner parties or just relaxing and connecting with nature,” says Glasser.
There’s also a balcony overlooking the treetops, making this listing feel even more magical.
In addition to this home’s amazing pedigree, Glasser says the location on Bedford Street and in the West Village is a huge draw.
“It’s in New York City’s most desirable neighborhood, surrounded by some of the best shops and restaurants,” she says.
