HomeReal EstateTiny Gingerbread Cottage on Martha’s Vineyard Hits the Market for $640K—but It...

Tiny Gingerbread Cottage on Martha’s Vineyard Hits the Market for $640K—but It Comes With a Unique Catch


A picturesque tiny house that is nestled in the historic Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meeting Association has just hit the market for $640,000—offering a “rare opportunity for year-round living” inside one of the area’s most idyllic communities.

However, the pint-sized property, which has shot to the top of the week’s most popular homes list, also comes with a very unique set of circumstances.

Located in the Oak Bluffs campground, the 354-square-foot, gingerbread cottage is small on space but large on asking price at $1,808 per square foot—and that doesn’t even include the land.

The community, once a former 19th century religious camp and designated National Historic Landmark, owns the property the homes sit on.

When purchasing this home, buyers become leaseholders and there is an application process required for membership in the MVCMA before closing on the home.

Built in 1870, the studio home with a covered front porch nestled in the popular summer rental community has been winterized for year-round residency. Recent modernizations throughout the small space include cathedral ceilings, a skylight, and hardwood floors.

Also grabbing attention this week are a Panther House in Oregon, a former jailhouse in Arkansas, and a condo built into the choir loft and bell tower of a former church in Pennsylvania.

10. 111 W Armstrong Ave, Peoria, IL

Price: $160,000

Why it’s here: It’s a former auto body shop that also once served as a plumbing business and photo studio before being transformed into a three-bedroom residence.

Built in 1920, the 1,903-square-foot structure zoned for both commercial and residential uses boasts a loft-style interior. Cathedral ceilings, hardwood and heated tile floors, exposed beams, hanging lights, and paneled walls are found throughout the home. An industrial-inspired kitchen has a three-basin sink, an oversized island, a pantry, and built-in coffee bar.

A spacious patio out front has a pizza oven.

Mike Van Cleve, of Re/Max Traders Unlimited, is the listing agent.

Peoria, IL (Realtor.com)

9. 15118 S 2815 W, Bluffdale, UT

Price: $6,500,000

Why it’s here: This luxurious 2025 Salt Lake Parade of Homes winner of the People’s Choice Award is tricked out with an indoor racquetball court, 20-seat home theater, and even a Hobbit room!

Designed for grand-scale entertaining, the “largest certified single-family Passive House in the world” boasts eight bedrooms, 10 bathrooms, three kitchens, a primary suite with private terrace, a fitness center, an entertainment level, and covered patios. A circular door opens up to the Hobbit-inspired room with arched doorways, exposed beams, and a fireplace, ideal for gatherings.

The recently built home also has an in-ground pool with water features, a slide, and a hot tub on the 1-acre, fenced lot.

Kerry Oman, of Summit Sotheby’s International Realty – Draper, is the listing agent.

Bluffdale, UT (Realtor.com)

8. 4470 Lakeview Blvd, Lake Oswego, OR

Price: $899,900

Why it’s here: The Panther House is a split-level residence known for its eye-popping mural on the two-car garage doors.

Located near West Bay, the three-bedroom home features a midcentury-inspired interior. Built in 1970, the 2,168-square-foot interior features a cozy living room with a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, an upper-level primary suite with access to a covered deck, and a guest suite on the main floor.

There is also a wine cellar with a tasting room for entertaining.

Christian Maluo, of Where, Inc., is the listing agent.

Lake Oswego, OR (Realtor.com)

7. 209 W River St, Ozark, AR

Price: $550,000

Why it’s here: Here’s the chance to own a former jailhouse that still features many original details, including iron doors, concrete walls, etchings of names from prisoners, and cell blocks that have been transformed into bedrooms!

Overlooking the Arkansas River, the waterfront property was built in 1914 and has been renovated into a three-bedroom dwelling. The concrete structure still features exposed brick and limestone walls and even comes with a metal shop. There is also a rooftop patio.

Plumbing, central heating, and air conditioning have all been updated, according to the listing.

Jeff Clifton, of Keller Williams Market Pro Realty – Rogers Branch, is the listing agent.

Ozark, AR (Realtor.com)

6. 12248 Dupont Rd, Hurley, WI

Price: $1,650,000

Why it’s here: Annala Farm is a 51.28-acre farmstead offering a primary residence, round fieldstone barn, and milkhouse tucked away along the Montreal River.

The historic compound built in 1938 features a five-bedroom stone home with covered front porch to soak in the serene views of the landscaped pond. A “showpiece” 60-foot round barn has exposed-stone walls, soaring ceilings, and lots of storage space for farm equipment and outdoor toys.

Located in the Northwoods, the sprawling property with snowmobile trails, apple trees, and gardens also has a newer two-car garage with a loft and multiple sheds, including one with guest accommodations.

Tim Riley, of Shorewest Realtors – Manitowish Waters, is the listing agent.

Hurley, WI (Realtor.com)

5. 31630 Forward Rd, Manton, CA

Price: $1,895,000

Why it’s here: Alger Vineyards located on 61.75 acres in Tehama and Shasta counties offers 26 acres devoted to syrah and petite sirah with an additional 6 acres featuring 10 other varietals.

Its 2,500-foot elevation and volcanic soils contribute to the success of the vineyard. Other highlights include “deeded senior ditch irrigation rights,” an irrigation well, and a stocked pond. There is also a four-bedroom primary residence, a two-bedroom caretaker’s house, a wine tasting room overlooking the vineyard, and a climate-controlled wine storage space.

The property is also approved for a winery “of up to 25,000 cases of wine per year” with zoning allowing for food services, events, and staff accommodations.

Scott Soder, of California Outdoor Properties, Inc., is the listing agent.

Manton, CA (Realtor.com)

4. 2132 Sarah St Unit 207, Pittsburgh, PA

Price: $875,000

Why it’s here: It’s a condo built into the choir loft and bell tower of the former St. Casimir Church.

Built in 1902, the four-story unit is nestled in the Baroque Revival-style structure that was purchased by developer Ivor Hill, who bought it in 2019 and transformed it into a 12-unit building. Ornate details include plaster arches, custom millwork, built-in seating, and oversized windows. Found throughout the 2,300-square-foot interior are a first-floor guest room and courtyard, a second-level main living area, and a primary suite spanning the top two floors.

Serious “wow factor” can be found in the bell tower views.

Sara Leitera, of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices The Preferred Realty – City, is the listing agent.

Pittsburgh, PA (Realtor.com)

3. 112 Schooland Rd, New Sweden, ME

Price: $449,900

Why it’s here: It’s a log cabin farmette tucked away on 108 wooded acres, including a portion of tillable farmland.

The retreat with wraparound deck is located in northern Maine on a “quiet dead-end road with minimal traffic.” Custom-built for someone who loves privacy and rural living, the remote residence built in 1998 boasts 1,920 square feet of rustic space. The interior features exposed beams, cathedral ceilings, expansive windows, and a floor-to-ceiling fieldstone fireplace. Two upstairs bedrooms have vaulted ceilings and peaceful views of spacious lot. The walkout lower level is ready to be customized.

A two-car insulated garage with pellet stove and storage, plus a playground area for children (equipment included) can also be found on property.

Daniel Castle, of NextHome Discover, is the listing agent.

New Sweden, ME (Realtor.com)

2. 7102 County Road 5, Effie, MN

Price: $159,000

Why it’s here: This affordable hunting and fishing retreat sits on 12 acres overlooking the Bigfork River.

The uniquely designed, two-bedroom residence boasts a 1,360-square-foot open floor plan. The three-story structure designed for outdoor enthusiasts offers three levels of decks and patios for relaxing and taking in the views of abundant wildlife.

A two-car garage with heated space and potential guest accommodations, along with two covered structures can also be found on property.

Gregory Anselmo, of Edge Of The Wilderness Realty, is the listing agent.

Effie, MN (Realtor.com)

1. 2 Lincoln Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA

Price: $640,000

Why it’s here: This tiny gingerbread home is tucked away in the historic Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meeting Association.

Offering just 354 square feet of space, the small winterized studio built in 1870 was fully renovated in 2023 and can be used year round. Cathedral ceilings make the space appear larger, and a galley kitchen boasts modern appliances.

A cute covered front porch overlooks the campground community.

Stacy A Ickes, of Donnelly Co., is the listing agent.

Oak Bluffs, MA (Realtor.com)
- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments